This page reveals the answer
Want to test yourself first? Play the original case before reading the clues and explanation below.
New here?
WhatsTheDx publishes a new Optometry case every day. Five clues, one diagnosis, and no account needed to play.
Play today's Optometry caseFive progressive clues
These are the case findings in their original reveal order, moving from the broader presentation to the most discriminating evidence.
Clue 1
An 8-year-old boy is brought in by his father because his right eyelid has swollen from puffy to completely closed since yesterday morning. He had a heavy cold for a week beforehand, with a blocked nose his father describes as constant.
Clue 2
His temperature is 38.6 °C and his heart rate is 118. There was no injury, no scratch and no insect bite, and his immunisations are up to date. White cell count is 17.8 × 10⁹/L with a neutrophilia and C-reactive protein is 96 mg/L.
Clue 3
Getting the lid open takes two people and some patience. Once it is held open, the conjunctiva is swollen and boggy over the white of the eye. He cries when asked to follow a finger from side to side — it is not the lid being touched that upsets him, it is moving the eye itself.
Clue 4
Measured rather than eyeballed, the right eye protrudes 5 mm further than the left. He cannot fully turn it outwards or lift it; both movements stop short. Vision in that eye is 20/40 against 20/20 on the other side.
Clue 5
There is no relative afferent pupillary defect, so the optic nerve is not yet compromised — which is the one piece of good news and the reason there is time to image rather than operate immediately. Imaging shows a completely opacified right ethmoid sinus and a 6 mm collection against the medial orbital wall, with no intracranial extension.
Diagnosis
Orbital Cellulitis
Why the diagnosis fits
Everything in this case turns on one anatomical line: the orbital septum. In front of it, a swollen infected lid is unpleasant but generally straightforward. Behind it, the infection is in the muscle and fat of the orbit — which is why this diagnosis is also called postseptal cellulitis — and it sits next to the optic nerve and a direct route into the skull. Three findings say the process is behind the septum, and they are the most important distinguishing features: restricted eye movement, pain on eye movement, and proptosis. He has all three. He cries when following a finger and it is the movement rather than the lid that upsets him; he cannot fully abduct or elevate; and measured rather than eyeballed, the eye protrudes 5 mm further than its fellow. Chemosis, fever and a peripheral leucocytosis all support it. Crucially, none of those three can be produced by an infection confined to the lid, because a lid infection has no mechanism to tether an extraocular muscle or push a globe forward. The history explains how it got there. He had a week of heavy upper respiratory illness with constant nasal blockage first, and in up to 86% to 98% of cases there is coexisting rhinosinusitis, with the ethmoid sinus — separated from the orbit by only a paper-thin wall — the one most likely to progress. His imaging shows exactly that: a completely opacified ethmoid and a 6 mm collection against the medial orbital wall. It is also worth noting what is absent: no injury, no scratch, no insect bite, which is the other common route to a swollen lid and would have pointed at the preseptal diagnosis instead. Two numbers govern what happens next. Vision has dropped to 20/40 from 20/20, which is a measurable threat rather than an impression, but there is no relative afferent pupillary defect, so the optic nerve is compromised rather than failing and there is time to image and treat medically. Management is empiric broad-spectrum intravenous antibiotics — vancomycin plus a cephalosporin — covering Staphylococcus aureus and Streptococcus species, for a minimum of two to three weeks. The surgical triggers are explicit and worth memorising, because this child sits just under all of them: an abscess larger than 10 mm, intracranial extension, or failure to improve within 24 to 48 hours. His collection is 6 mm with no intracranial spread, so he is admitted, treated and watched closely — and the acuity is what is being watched.
Educational reference
The explanation and decisive case findings were checked against the source below.
Open the clinical referenceFor education and entertainment only. This fictional case is not medical advice and does not replace supervised clinical training, diagnosis, or treatment.
Play today's Optometry case